Trusts play a significant role in many estate plans because they allow individuals to manage and distribute property with structure and long-term oversight. When establishing a trust, one of the earliest decisions involves choosing between a revocable trust and an irrevocable trust. A revocable trust can be changed freely during the creator’s lifetime, while an irrevocable trust is designed to remain fixed once it is executed. This permanence offers meaningful planning advantages, but it can create challenges when changing circumstances make the original terms impractical or unsuitable. When such a situation occurs, decanting a trust may offer an effective solution. The Eghrari Wealth Training Firm explain what it means to decant a trust in New York and why it may be necessary.
Understanding the Distinction Between Revocable and Irrevocable Trusts
A revocable trust allows the individual who created it, known as the Settlor, to amend or revoke the trust at any point while they are living and legally competent. This flexibility makes revocable trusts attractive for people who want the ability to adjust their estates as life evolves. An irrevocable trust operates very differently. Once the trust document is signed and funded, the Settlor generally relinquishes the ability to modify the terms. This structure is intentional because an irrevocable trust removes assets from the Settlor’s ownership, thereby providing benefits such as asset protection, potential tax advantages, and insulation from certain creditors. The trade-off is that changes to the document are usually extremely limited or entirely unavailable.
Reasons an Irrevocable Trust May Need Adjustment
Because life is unpredictable, estate planning documents occasionally become misaligned with your present needs and goals. A shift in tax law, a change in the value of trust property, or new financial or personal circumstances for beneficiaries, for instance, may all create tension between what the trust provides and what the situation demands. A frequent example arises when a revocable trust becomes irrevocable after the Settlor’s death, leaving a surviving spouse as the remainder beneficiary. The Trustee may have broad discretion, yet the existing language might not adequately address new realities. In such cases, the Trustee might determine that a modification is in the best interest of the beneficiaries, but the trust terms do not grant authority to alter the document. When that is the case, decanting may be the most suitable method to respond to these developments.
Other motivations for altering an irrevocable trust can include correcting drafting mistakes, adjusting the ages at which beneficiaries receive distributions, expanding asset protection mechanisms available to the Trustee, moving the trust to another jurisdiction to address tax issues, changing or adding a successor Trustee, granting a power of appointment, or incorporating provisions for a beneficiary with special needs. Each of these circumstances reflects the need for a modernized trust that continues to serve the Settlor’s broader intentions.
How Decanting Works
The word “decanting” is often associated with wine. When wine is poured from the original bottle into a new vessel, sediment is left behind, improving the quality of what remains. Decanting a trust relies on that same concept. The valuable provisions of an older trust are transferred into a new trust with updated terms, leaving behind language that no longer serves the beneficiaries. There are two ways to decant a trust. The first involves the Trustee establishing a new trust and then distributing the property from the old trust into the new one. The second method involves the Trustee transferring assets into an existing trust that already contains more beneficial terms. In both instances, the purpose is to refine the trust without eliminating its original purpose.
Decanting a Trust Under New York Law
In some instances, the Settlor of a trust explicitly grants decanting authority to the Trustee within the trust agreement itself. Even when the trust agreement is silent, many states, including New York, have enacted statutes that allow a Trustee to decant under specific conditions. Under New York law, a Trustee with unlimited discretion is required to create a new trust agreement and transfer assets from the old trust into the new one.
There are circumstances in which decanting may not be permitted. If the trust explicitly forbids decanting, the Trustee is bound by that restriction. If a beneficiary already holds a legally enforceable right to receive distributions, that right cannot typically be altered through decanting. The Trustee’s authority is also central to the process. A trust that grants only minimal discretion to the Trustee may not qualify. Most trusts provide some level of discretionary authority to distribute assets for the beneficiaries’ support, health, or education, yet the specific language of the document will determine whether decanting is legally available.
Can We Help You Decant a Trust in New York?
Please join us for an upcoming FREE seminar. If you find yourself in a position where you need to decant a trust in New York, contact the Long Island estate planning attorneys at Eghrari Wealth Training Firm by calling us at 631-265-0599 to schedule your appointment.
Legacy Planning in Your New York Estate Plan
See Larger Map
Get Directions